Skip to content
Gifts wrapped in kraft and cream paper with twine on a wooden table by a window.

Gifts for Father-in-Law When You’re Still Figuring Him Out

Updated 18 hand-picked ideas

Safe and still personal

  1. Our first pickGourmet Steak Gift BoxOn Amazonabout $140
  2. YMI Pasadena 15-Inch Wooden Backgammon Set
    To play togetherWooden Backgammon Set with Folding BoardOn Amazonabout $50
  3. Aura Carver 10.1-Inch Wi-Fi Digital Photo Frame
    From the grandkidsSmart Digital Photo FrameOn Amazonabout $150
  4. Tovolo Sphere Clear Ice Mold
    Under $15Whiskey Ice Ball MoldOn Amazonabout $13

Giftruly is reader-supported. When you buy through our links we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. How we pick

The short answer

While you’re still figuring him out, give something good he can eat, drink or play: Omaha Steaks filet mignons for a first Christmas, Glencairn whiskey glasses if he keeps a nice bottle, or a wooden backgammon set the two of you can play after dinner. If there are grandkids, an Aura photo frame wins every time.

Buying for a father-in-law is a slightly odd assignment. You may have known him for two years or twenty, but you joined his family as an adult, so you missed the decades of background that make shopping for your own parents easier. He’s often polite, a little reserved around you and impossible to read on the subject of presents. You want the gift to say "I’m glad to be part of this family" without looking like you’re trying too hard.

The good news is that you have an inside source. This guide starts with how to make the most of your partner’s knowledge, then moves through gifts that are safe without being dull, things the two of you can do together, gifts that come from the grandkids and a short list of small extras.

If it’s June, our Father’s Day gifts for father-in-law guide is built for that day specifically. Shopping for both of your partner’s parents? See gifts for mother-in-law too, and if he’s a grandfather many times over, gifts for grandpa has more ideas.

Shopping for Christmas?Christmas Gifts for Father-in-Law

Keeping it comfortable

  • Match the gift to how well you know him. In the early years, choose something good he can use or enjoy; save the deeply personal gifts until you’ve built some history together.

  • Avoid clothes unless your partner is certain of his size and taste. Shirts and sweaters are the gifts most likely to end up at the back of a closet.

  • Don’t outspend his own children. A gift that dwarfs what your partner’s siblings give can feel awkward for everyone, and a joint gift with your partner sidesteps the problem.

  • Write a line in the card yourself. One or two sentences in your own handwriting about something you appreciate in him can matter more than the gift.

  • Still unsure? Describe him to our gift finder, mention that he’s your father-in-law and what your partner says he enjoys, and you’ll get a shortlist with reasons.

Father-in-law gift questions

What’s a good first gift for a new father-in-law?

Something good that he can eat, drink or use every day: a box of steaks, a set of whiskey glasses, a coffee canister or a leather valet tray. Give it from you and your partner together, and save more personal gifts for later years.

How much should I spend on a gift for my father-in-law?

Roughly what your partner would spend on their own parent, which for most families is somewhere between $30 and $80. Going far above that can feel like showing off, and going far below can look careless.

Should the gift be from me or from both of us?

In most families, both of you. A joint gift is normal, it lets your partner weigh in, and it takes the pressure off. You can still add your own line to the card if you want him to know you had a hand in choosing it.

What do you get a father-in-law who has everything?

Choose something consumable, an activity you can share or a gift that features the grandkids. For a man whose garage and closets are already full, those three routes are the least likely to add clutter, and you’ll find plenty more in our gifts for someone who has everything guide.