~$150
Adjustable Kettlebell
Offers a flexible strength-training option without filling a room with equipment.
Fitness Fanspractical

~$330 typical price
BowFlex SelectTech 552 Dumbbells
Dumbbells that adjust from 5 to 52.5 lbs with a dial.
Why it makes a great gift
Replaces a whole rack of weights in a corner of the room.
Offers a flexible strength-training option without filling a room with equipment.
Gymreapers Workout Journal
Helps a goal-oriented athlete notice progress that can be hard to see day to day.

BlenderBottle Radian Insulated Shaker
Plastic shakers start to smell after a few months; steel is the upgrade few people buy for themselves.

Harbinger Padded Cotton Lifting Straps
Inexpensive accessories that regular lifters wear out and replace, and that fit almost anyone.