~$35
Cashmere Blend Lounge Socks
Everyone owns socks, almost nobody owns cashmere ones, which makes them a small, genuine upgrade.
HomebodiesFashion Lovers

~$25 typical price
The Peanut Shop of Williamsburg Peanut Brittle
Buttery peanut brittle made in small batches and packed in a gift tin.
Why it makes a great gift
A nostalgic sweet that a lot of older people grew up with, and the tin gets reused for years.
Everyone owns socks, almost nobody owns cashmere ones, which makes them a small, genuine upgrade.

One of the few games that comfortably seats eight players, from grade-schoolers to great-grandparents.

Hours of the films many grandfathers grew up on, playable on a basic DVD player with no streaming account.
Adds real smoke to a gas grill, or extra smoke to a pellet grill, for very little money.