~$55
Sailor's Rigging Knife with Marlinspike
A classic, useful sailing tool that gets carried every time they're on board.
Boaters & Paddlerspractical

~$40 typical price
John Rousmaniere's large illustrated reference on sailing, boat handling, navigation and safety.
Why it makes a great gift
One of the standard reference books for sailors, used by beginners and kept on board by experienced crews.
A classic, useful sailing tool that gets carried every time they're on board.

It shows the water they know best in the format they actually navigate with, so it means more than a generic beach print.

ACR RapidDitch Express Bag
Offshore boaters keep a packed grab bag for emergencies, and a proper one is often on the to-do list for years.

Seachoice Universal Boat Kill Switch Kit
If the driver goes overboard the engine stops, and a spare matters because the original always seems to go missing.