
Gifts for True Crime Fans Who Love the Investigation
By the Gift DeskUpdated 17 hand-picked ideas
The short list
- The book to start withI'll Be Gone in the Dark by Michelle McNamaraOn Amazonabout $11

- Solve one togetherCold Case Murder Mystery Case File GameOn Amazonabout $30
- For podcast nightsBluetooth Sleep Headband HeadphonesOn Amazonabout $13
Giftruly is reader-supported. When you buy through our links we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. How we pick
The short answer
Start with the books that hold up: Michelle McNamara’s I’ll Be Gone in the Dark, Capote’s In Cold Blood or Say Nothing. For a fan who’d rather solve one, an Unsolved Case File game or a murder-mystery dinner party kit turns the hobby into an evening with friends.
Ask a true crime fan what draws them in and the answer is rarely the crime itself. It’s the investigation: the detective who wouldn’t let a case go, the overlooked clue, the forensic breakthrough decades later, the journalist who got the truth out. Many fans are also fiercely interested in how the justice system works, and fails. The best gifts lean into that curiosity.
This guide starts with the books that set the standard for the genre, then covers gifts for the fan who falls asleep to podcasts, and games that let them play detective with friends. There’s a short, plain section on respect, because these stories involve real people, and a few small, lighthearted extras to finish.
If they love solving more than reading, gifts for puzzle lovers and gifts for board game fans have plenty more. For a reader whose tastes go beyond the genre, see gifts for book lovers.
Choosing well for a true crime fan
Lean into what fascinates them: investigation, forensics, history or justice. The best gifts reflect that, not the gore.
Skip merchandise that celebrates killers or uses real crime scene imagery. Most fans find it distasteful too.
Ask which podcasts and documentaries they love. It tells you whether they prefer forensic detail, historical cases or courtroom drama.
Fictional mysteries are a great way to enjoy the detective work together, without anyone’s real tragedy involved.
For more personalized ideas, describe them to our gift finder.
True crime gift questions
What’s a good gift for someone obsessed with true crime?
A classic true crime book like I’ll Be Gone in the Dark or Killers of the Flower Moon, a sleep headband for listening to podcasts in bed, or a cold case game they can solve with friends.
What true crime books make good gifts?
I’ll Be Gone in the Dark, In Cold Blood, Killers of the Flower Moon, Say Nothing and The Poisoner’s Handbook are all well-reported, widely praised and inexpensive. They cover very different cases and eras, so you can choose one that matches their interests.
Is true crime merchandise appropriate as a gift?
Jokes about the hobby, like a mug about podcast binges, are usually fine. Anything that glamorizes a real killer or uses real victims or crime scenes is best avoided, and many fans would be uncomfortable receiving it.
What do you get a teenager who loves true crime?
Steer toward the investigative side. A forensic science lab kit, a fictional cold case game or a mystery jigsaw puzzle all scratch the detective itch, and The Poisoner’s Handbook suits an older teen who likes science. Many true crime books and podcasts include disturbing detail, so check the content before passing one on.
What are cheap gifts for true crime fans?
Any of the books on this page, a case notes journal, the classic game Clue, a murder mystery jigsaw puzzle or a podcast-themed mug all cost $25 or less.









