Gifts for True Crime Fans Who Love the Investigation

By the Gift DeskUpdated October 8, 202618 hand-picked ideas

The ideas at a glance

I'll Be Gone in the Dark by Michelle McNamara~$11
In Cold Blood by Truman Capote~$17
Killers of the Flower Moon by David Grann~$11
Say Nothing by Patrick Radden Keefe~$18
The Poisoner's Handbook by Deborah Blum~$11
Bluetooth Sleep Headband Headphones~$9

Ask a true crime fan what draws them in and the answer is rarely the crime itself. It’s the investigation: the detective who wouldn’t let a case go, the overlooked clue, the forensic breakthrough decades later, the journalist who got the truth out. Many fans are also fiercely interested in how the justice system works, and fails. The best gifts lean into that curiosity.

This guide starts with the books that set the standard for the genre, then covers gifts for the fan who falls asleep to podcasts, and games that let them play detective with friends. There’s a short, plain section on respect, because these stories involve real people, and a few small, lighthearted extras to finish.

If they love solving more than reading, gifts for puzzle lovers and gifts for board game fans have plenty more. For a reader whose tastes go beyond the genre, see gifts for book lovers.

Shopping for Christmas?Open the Christmas gift finder

Giftruly is reader-supported. When you buy through our links we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. How we pick

The books that hold up

Podcasts and documentaries come and go, but the best true crime books are serious reporting that has lasted. Each of these takes the victims seriously and tells you something larger than the case. They also make easy gifts: they’re inexpensive, and even devoted fans often haven’t read them all.

Our favorite1
I'll Be Gone in the Dark by Michelle McNamara
Michelle McNamara spent years investigating the serial offender she named the Golden State Killer, and died before finishing the book; colleagues completed it from her notes. A suspect was arrested shortly after it came out. It’s as much about obsession and grief as about the case, and it’s careful to keep the victims at the center. A natural first pick for any fan of the genre.
On Amazonabout $11
2
In Cold Blood by Truman Capote
Capote’s account of the 1959 murder of the Clutter family in rural Kansas, and the two men convicted of it, is the book that shaped the modern genre. Many fans know the title without having read it. Later reporting showed Capote reshaped some details for effect, which makes it an interesting read for someone curious about where the genre’s habits began.
On Amazonabout $17
3
Killers of the Flower Moon by David Grann
In 1920s Oklahoma, members of the Osage Nation were being murdered for the oil wealth on their land, and the investigation helped shape the young FBI. Grann’s book is gripping, and it brings to light a crime that many Americans were never taught about. A strong pick for a fan who also loves history, or who saw the film and wants the full story.
On Amazonabout $11
4
Say Nothing by Patrick Radden Keefe
Built around the 1972 abduction of Jean McConville, a widowed mother of ten, in Belfast, this book widens into a history of the Troubles and the people who kept their silence for decades. It’s long and deeply researched. Give it to the fan who likes a case that opens onto bigger questions about violence, loyalty and memory.
On Amazonabout $18
5
The Poisoner's Handbook by Deborah Blum
The story of New York’s first medical examiner and his toxicologist, who built forensic science from almost nothing during Prohibition. It’s for the fan most fascinated by how cases get solved, with plenty of chemistry told in an accessible way. A clever choice for someone who’s been through every forensic documentary on their streaming service.
On Amazonabout $11

Know exactly who it’s for?

For the fan who falls asleep to podcasts

A huge number of true crime fans listen more than they read, often in bed, on a commute or while doing chores. These gifts make the listening more comfortable.

6
Bluetooth Sleep Headband Headphones
A soft headband with flat speakers inside, so they can listen in bed without earbuds digging in when they roll over. It’s a small comfort that makes a big difference for side sleepers. It also doubles as an eye mask on a plane, and as a way to listen without keeping a partner awake.
On Amazonabout $9
7
Noise-Masking Sleep Earbuds
Ozlo Sleepbuds 2
Tiny earbuds designed to be worn lying down, with a sleep timer so an episode doesn’t play all night. They’re expensive for earbuds, so they suit a dedicated nightly listener, or someone who shares a bed with a snorer. For occasional listeners, the headband above is the gentler price.
On Amazonabout $280
8
Audible Gift Membership
Many of the best true crime books are excellent on audio, and a membership gives them a credit each month to spend on whichever title they like. It’s a natural fit for a podcast fan who’s run out of new episodes. Check they don’t already subscribe, since doubling up isn’t much of a gift.
On Amazonabout $149

Play detective together

These are fictional mysteries, which makes them a fun, guilt-free way to enjoy the detective work fans love. Most are best with friends or a partner, and the case file games in particular reward the fan who notices small inconsistencies in a witness statement. Check the player count on the box before you buy.

9
Cold Case Murder Mystery Case File Game
A box of fictional police reports, statements and photos to work through over an evening or two. The closest thing to working a case.
On Amazonabout $30
10
Murder Mystery Dinner Party Kit
A Taste for Wine and Murder
Character cards, clues and a script for a dinner where one guest is the culprit. Great for a fan who loves hosting.
On Amazonabout $20
11
Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle Game
White Mountain Hollywood Murder-Mystery Puzzle
Read the story, build the puzzle, then find the clues hidden in the finished picture. A quiet weekend project for one or two.
On Amazonabout $20
12
Escape Room in a Box Game
Locks, codes and puzzles against the clock at home. A good date night or party game for people who like a challenge.
On Amazonabout $16
13
Classic Clue Mystery Board Game
The original whodunit, easy enough for kids and still fun for adults. A good family pick for a younger fan.
On Amazonabout $14
14
Forensic Science Lab Kit for Teens
Carolina Biological Master Forensics Kit
Fingerprinting, fiber tests and safe lab experiments. For a teenager who watches crime shows and might like forensic science as a career.
On Amazonabout $40

A word on respect

Every true crime story involves real people, and their families are still living with what happened. Most fans are well aware of this, and many are uncomfortable with merchandise that treats killers as celebrities or turns real crimes into decor. Skip anything printed with a murderer’s face or name, crime scene imagery or jokes about a specific case. It’s also worth avoiding gifts tied to recent, unresolved cases that are still being investigated.

A thoughtful alternative to merchandise is a donation in their name. Some nonprofits raise money to pay for DNA testing in cold cases, and local organizations support victims and their families. For a fan who cares about justice, that kind of gift can mean more than anything on this page. The small extras below are lighthearted jokes about the hobby itself, not about anyone’s tragedy, which is the line most fans would draw.

Small, wry extras

Cheap, funny gifts that poke fun at the habit of listening to murder podcasts while folding laundry.

15.
True Crime Case Notes Journal
Pages for timelines, theories and episode notes. For the fan who already scribbles questions while a podcast plays.
On Amazonabout $14
16.
Detective Evidence Board with Red String Kit
A cork board with pins and red string. Fun for theorizing about a mystery novel, or for planning a wedding.
On Amazonabout $28
17.
Murder Podcast and Chill Coffee Mug
The True Crime Podcast Coffee Mug
A dry joke about the listening habit, not any case. A cheap office gift for the coworker who recommends episodes.
On Amazonabout $15
18.
True Crime and Chill Throw Blanket
This Is My True Crime Watching Blanket
A soft fleece throw for documentary marathons on the couch. Cozy, a little silly and easy to give.
On Amazonabout $28

Shop this guide by price

Choosing well for a true crime fan

Lean into what fascinates them: investigation, forensics, history or justice. The best gifts reflect that, not the gore.
Skip merchandise that celebrates killers or uses real crime scene imagery. Most fans find it distasteful too.
Ask which podcasts and documentaries they love. It tells you whether they prefer forensic detail, historical cases or courtroom drama.
Fictional mysteries are a great way to enjoy the detective work together, without anyone’s real tragedy involved.
For more personalized ideas, describe them to our gift finder.

True crime gift questions

What’s a good gift for someone obsessed with true crime?

A classic true crime book like I’ll Be Gone in the Dark or Killers of the Flower Moon, a sleep headband for listening to podcasts in bed, or a cold case game they can solve with friends.

What true crime books make good gifts?

I’ll Be Gone in the Dark, In Cold Blood, Killers of the Flower Moon, Say Nothing and The Poisoner’s Handbook are all well-reported, widely praised and inexpensive. They cover very different cases and eras, so you can choose one that matches their interests.

Is true crime merchandise appropriate as a gift?

Jokes about the hobby, like a mug about podcast binges, are usually fine. Anything that glamorizes a real killer or uses real victims or crime scenes is best avoided, and many fans would be uncomfortable receiving it.

What do you get a teenager who loves true crime?

Steer toward the investigative side. A forensic science lab kit, a fictional cold case game or a mystery jigsaw puzzle all scratch the detective itch, and The Poisoner’s Handbook suits an older teen who likes science. Many true crime books and podcasts include disturbing detail, so check the content before passing one on.

What are cheap gifts for true crime fans?

Any of the books on this page, a case notes journal, the classic game Clue, a murder mystery jigsaw puzzle or a podcast-themed mug all cost $25 or less.

Gifts for History Buffs Gifts for Puzzle Lovers Last-Minute Christmas Gifts Gifts for Minimalists Long-Distance Gifts Three Kings Day Gifts

The books that hold up

Know exactly who it’s for?

For the fan who falls asleep to podcasts

Play detective together

A word on respect

Small, wry extras

Shop this guide by price

Under $25

$25–$50

$100+

Choosing well for a true crime fan

True crime gift questions

Related gift guides

The books that hold up

Know exactly who it’s for?

For the fan who falls asleep to podcasts

Play detective together

A word on respect

Small, wry extras

Shop this guide by price

Under $25

$25–$50

$100+