~$13
Bluetooth Sleep Headband Headphones
Lets a podcast fan fall asleep to their show without earbuds digging in.
True Crime FansSelf-Care Lovers

~$280 typical price
Ozlo Sleepbuds 2
Tiny wireless earbuds designed to be worn lying on your side, with noise masking and a sleep timer.
Why it makes a great gift
Great for falling asleep to a podcast without waking with an ear sore from regular buds.
Lets a podcast fan fall asleep to their show without earbuds digging in.

The True Crime Podcast Coffee Mug
Cheap, funny and clearly aimed at this exact fan.

A Taste for Wine and Murder
Turns a regular dinner into a game and gives the host everything needed.
Looks the part for a crime fan, and works for real planning too.