~$20
Felt Santa Boot to Fill
Gives Saint Nicholas Eve its own boot instead of a muddy school shoe, and comes out again every year.
cozysentimental

~$25 typical price
A Christmas stocking with the baby's name embroidered or printed on the cuff.
Why it makes a great gift
The family needs a stocking for the new baby anyway, and a named one hangs on the mantel for years.
Gives Saint Nicholas Eve its own boot instead of a muddy school shoe, and comes out again every year.

Matching pajamas make the Christmas morning photo, and a set can be opened on Christmas Eve to wear that night.

BabyBibi Floating Bath Books, Set of 2
A cheap way to add a story to the bath routine without ruining a real book.
It keeps a wet baby's head warm and gets used from the first bath into the toddler years.