~$30
Cold Case Murder Mystery Case File Game
Our pick: Unsolved Case File: Sherlock vs Jack the Ripper
Feels like detective work, which is what true crime fans often enjoy most.
True Crime FansBoard Game Fans

~$20 typical price
A deck of questions about famous cases, investigations and forensic history.
Why it makes a great gift
Works as a conversation starter for friends who already share a podcast list.
Our pick: Unsolved Case File: Sherlock vs Jack the Ripper
Feels like detective work, which is what true crime fans often enjoy most.

A friendly family version of detective play that most people already know.

The True Crime Podcast Coffee Mug
Cheap, funny and clearly aimed at this exact fan.

A Taste for Wine and Murder
Turns a regular dinner into a game and gives the host everything needed.